Got the replacement .40 caliber ammo today, entirely free. 50 rounds of 180gr XTP hp ammo.
Very impressed with their customer service. They made a mistake and fixed it free and promptly.
In the end, with the coupon and free ammo replacement - worked out to
2 boxes (50 rds) of Hornady XTP 185 gr. .45acp (mismarked on their site, now corrected) for only $15 shipped after rebate/coupon.
2 boxes (50 rds) of Hornady XTP 180 gr. .40acp (the product I thought I was ordering originally) for free.
100 rounds of premium HP ammo for $15.